Book Review: I Let You Go

Clare Mackintosh in her Chipping Norton home in the Cotswalds of England where she served as a police sergeant and launched her literary career.

Why don’t you leave? Clare Mackintosh answers this question in graphic detail in her debut international bestseller I Let You Go.  She also provides brilliant insights into the twisted minds and malignant narcissism of perpetrators of violence against women.  It is a psychological thriller that I could not put down until I read all 369 pages yesterday.  Be prepared to laugh, cry, and gasp.

Clare Mackintosh

I Let You Go is set in the author’s hometown of Bristol, England.  She served as a police officer in Oxford where joyriders killed a boy in a still-unsolved hit and run.  She also gave birth to twins Josh and Alex in 2006.  Sadly, Alex died shortly after birth from meningitis.  Several months later, she unexpectedly became pregnant with a second set of twins, Evie and Georgie.

Clare Mackintosh with her children, Evie, Josh, and Georgie

The unsolved hit and run and Alex’s death became the center of I Let You Go which has a plot twist in the middle of the book I didn’t see coming because I didn’t carefully process the author’s note at the end of the book:

When my own son died. . .I experienced firsthand how emotion can cloud one’s judgment and affect behavior.  Grief and guilt are powerful feelings, and I began to wonder how they might affect two women involved in very different ways in the same incident.  [emphasis added]

Jenna Gray and Ray and Kate, the police officers investigating the hit-and-run, are the central characters of the first half of the book.  Is the tension between Ray and Kate sexual harassment or consensual?  Jenna has horrendous PTSD and decamps to the Welsh coast.  Why?  I’m not gonna tell.

A message in the sand akin to those Jenna creates and photographs

Jenna had been a sculptor in Bristol, but a mysterious injury to her hand ends her career.  Her Welsh neighbor Bethan encourages her to market the photos she takes on the beach which becomes her safe haven.

Clare Mackintosh with a mug of tea which is as much a part of the plot as the characters.

Why wouldn’t you let us help you?
Because he would have killed me.
– Clare Mackintosh, I Let You Go

Critics have opined the book is akin to The Girl on the Train.  I disagree.  It captures the experience of domestic violence as brilliantly as Black and Blue by Anna Quindlen.  I accurately intuited some of the plot twists, but I still gasped when they unfolded.

While I recommend the book highly, it may not be a wise choice for some survivors ~ especially protective mothers ~ who have Complex-PTSD.  The PTSD episodes and traumatic events Jenna experiences are quite graphic.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s