Why I think Sen. Al Franken is innocent

Sen. Al Franken (D-MN)

When the allegations of sexual assault and harassment against Sen. Al Franken (D-MN) first surfaced, I was outraged and felt betrayed. As the story unfolded, however, I will confess that I was embarrassed that I had allowed myself to be so easily manipulated by what now appears to be a brilliantly orchestrated political hit job.

The kiss obviously isn’t what his accuser alleged. He is kissing her on the cheek as she requested during rehearsal.

We are in an era of #MeToo; many of us have raw emotions close to the surface; we don’t want to call “bullshit!” on a woman because we know all too well the sting of slut-shaming and victim-blaming; we know the humiliation attendant with sexual harassment. When we are called to sisterhood, we show up.

Leeann Tweeden’s allegations don’t meet the legal elements of sexual assault or harassment.

And, that’s exactly what abusive assholes like Steve Bannon knew would happen. Yes, he’s a brilliant strategist. He’s also a ruthless and evil bastard who relishes the abuse of power. He needs a foil for his damaged candidate Judge Roy Moore. #NoMoore.  As a bonus, he may take out Donald Trump’s chief critic ~ a man with rare integrity ~ a man unafraid to speak truth to power:  Sen. Al Franken.

I want to thank everyone I’ve been blessed to meet via Facebook who brought valuable insights and information to this issue. We had a respectful dialogue, and I think we have surfaced the truth.

Sean Hannity, Steve Bannon, and Judge Roy Moore

Back in the day, I worked with Gerry Skoning at Seyfarth, Shaw, Fairweather & Geraldson, the attorney who “wrote the book” on defending powerful men from charges of sexual harassment. When I see his strategy playing out (Judge Roy Moore, Bill Cosby, etc.), I instantly know the man is guilty as charged. Sen. Al Franken, however, came forward with an apology so many of us have waited decades to hear from just one man. He wasn’t operating out of Gerry’s “predators’ play book.” When I read it, I realized that I needed to examine the evidence carefully and consider the law. Ultimately, I realized we’d all been played. And, it pissed me off.

This is clearly a gag photo. You can see the shadow beneath Al Franken’s hands which indicates he did not, in fact, grope her. Bad taste? Absolutely. Criminal? Hell no!

When we hear allegations of sexual misconduct, we tend to take them at face value.  Most people don’t take the time to check the legal elements to see whether they have been met.  We hear a wide variety of inappropriate sexual behavior categorized as sexual harassment.  I think it is time to examine the legal elements for sexual harassment and apply them to the facts of this case:

Harassment on the basis of sex is a violation of Sec. 703 of Title VII. Unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature constitutes sexual harassment when (1) submission to such conduct is made either explicitly or implicitly a term or condition of an individual’s employment, (2) submission to or rejection of such conduct by an individual is used as the basis for employment decisions affecting such individual, or (3) such conduct that has the purpose or effect of unreasonably interfering with an individual’s work performance or creating an intimidating, hostile, or offensive environment. [Source: American Bar Association]


Back in the day, it galled me how many women were more than willing trade sexual favors for career advancement.  These photos of Leeann Tweeden’s sexual aggressiveness cause me to wonder whether the person who actually said “no” was Al Franken.  That’s what has always bugged me about this story.  He is totally devoted to his wife and isn’t the kind of guy who would “go out for hamburger when he had steak at home.”  Predators retaliate.  The question is who is the real predator?


Leeann Tweeden grabbing the guitar player’s butt on the USO tour


Leeann Tweeden making passes at Robin Williams

There’s a reason the accuser doesn’t want an investigation:  she knows the legal elements for sexual assault and harassment haven’t, in fact, been met.  Sen. Franken, in contrast, wants an investigation so that he can clear his name.  Guilty people don’t do this.  They rely instead on Gerry’s playbook.  They slut-shame the victim and try to discredit her.

Bill and Hillary Clinton

Bannon’s fired up Trump’s base by ignoring Trump’s admission on the Access Hollywood tape that he’s the pussy-grabber-in-chief ~ a shameless serial sexual predator.  He’s trotted out Pres. Bill Clinton’s impeachment for lying about his affair with Monica Lewinsky to suggest that Democrats have a double standard.  I’ve always thought this was a case of sexual harassment.  And, I thought the only person who had the right to toss him out of the White House was Hillary.  Hell, I would have helped her pack his sorry ass up.

Sen. Bob Packwood (R-OR) was forced out of office after allegations of sexual harassment were published in the Washington Post.

In 1992, I joined with labor attorney Susan Hammer and Oregon Women Lawyers (OWL) to oust Sen. Bob Packwood (R-OR) from office.  Over dinner, OWL members chatted about whether we believed Anita Hill, who alleged that SCOTUS candidate Clarence Thomas had sexually harassed her when he was charged with prosecuting sexual harassment at the EEOC.

Every woman at the table except me had been on the receiving end of Packwood’s penchant for tongue hockey.  I was new to Oregon and hadn’t had the misfortune of meeting him yet.  He was gross and creepy.  The Oregonian didn’t take the allegations seriously, and the Washington Post didn’t timely publish their investigation.  I was surprised to recently discover that Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-KY) initiated the ethics hearing which culminated in Packwood’s resignation.  Sen. McConnell is one of Judge Moore’s chief critics.

Pedophile and former House Speaker Denny Hastert (R-IL) being wheeled into prison by his wife.

Let’s not forget that Rep. Denny Hastert (R-IL) was the chief proponent of Pres. Clinton’s impeachment.  We didn’t know at the time that Hastert was a pedophile who had committed statutory rape with several boys on his high school wresting team.  When it comes to sexual predators, the GOP has their own dirty laundry.  So, how about we ditch the double standard bullshit and focus on the facts of the case.

Al Franken and Leeann Tweeden working in harmony to entertain the troops

Was Al Franken’s behavior inappropriate, unprofessional, and offensive?  Yes.  His career was founded on SNL’s “wild and crazy guys” culture.  He’s matured and now admits that much of their humor was offensive.  His accuser called him on the kiss during rehearsal.  As you can see from the photo, he complied with her demand to kiss her on the cheek, and it certainly doesn’t appear her work environment was hostile.

Sen. Franken’s apology had me in tears.  It was humble, contrite, and sincere.  I’ve waited decades to hear just one guy apologize for what happened to so many of us throughout our careers.  His accuser has accepted his apology and would like for all of us to move on.

If Sen. Al Franken was, in fact, a predator, we would have heard a chorus of #MeToo by now. We didn’t. The sound we are hearing is Steve Bannon’s laughter. He suckered us once again.  #NoMoore

Brilliant post:

“A Survivor’s Defense of Al Franken” by Dr. G.S. Potter, 11/22/17

7 responses to “Why I think Sen. Al Franken is innocent

  1. The “guitar player” is actually Mark Wills, he was one of the main acts. I’m curious how he feels about getting his butt grabbed.

  2. Thank you, Amanda. After I published this post, I found a video of the 2006 USO tour on YouTube. About minute six, she spontaneously walks over to him and grinds her butt on him. He pushes her away and does a lot of mumbling later about sexual harassment. The body language says to me that she was offering, but he wasn’t remotely interested in buying. My guess is that he was offended and embarrassed that she would come onto him so publicly. Dunno. Hope someone in the media watches the tape and asks the question.

    Best wishes,
    Anne Caroline

  3. This whole sexual harrassment charade regarding Senator Franken is nothing more than a cheap attack from the Trump administration.

    Stop it Donald! Stop kicking sand in the eyes of your opponents! Live and let live! Stop being so darn close minded! Have a heart!

    Senator Franken has done more for American than Trump could ever envision. Besides Senator Franken is an Ivy League scholar. Try and top that Pres. Donald!

  4. Pingback: Cream: Goodbye (1969) - Progrography·

  5. Megan,

    Thanks for your comment. You might enjoy Michael Wolff’s book Fire and Fury which will be published next Tuesday (1/9). He absolutely skewers Trump.

    Wishing you all the best,
    Anne Caroline

  6. Pingback: [Review] Cream: Goodbye (1969) - Progrography·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s